Agency versus in-house recruitment is a choice to make role by role, and the faster route depends on which part of a hire takes longest. An agency can shorten the search for candidates your team can’t reach, while everything after the first interview runs at your own hiring team’s pace, whoever found the candidate.
When a role stalls, the usual fix is to bring in an agency. That helps when the delay was in finding candidates. When it was in feedback and decisions, the agency’s candidates join the same slow queue as everyone else, and the role fills no sooner.
I recommend looking at where the days went on your last few similar hires before you choose, rather than picking one model for the whole company.
This guide is for talent leaders deciding whether an open role should go to an agency. It shows how to tell which route will fill each role faster, and how to work with an agency so its candidates don’t sit waiting on your team.
Find where the days go on your recent hires.
Before you choose a route for an open role, look at how the last few similar hires went. Split each hire into two parts, the search and the process, because an agency can speed up the search and can do little about the process. Here’s how:
- Pick the last three to five hires for roles like the one that’s open.
- For each hire, count the days from the role’s approval to the first hiring manager interview with a candidate who met the brief. This is the search: finding candidates and getting them to talk to you.
- Count the days from that interview to the accepted offer. This is the process: the interviews, the feedback, the decision, and the offer.
- Write down the main thing that held up the slower part, such as a brief the hiring manager changed partway through.
Your applicant tracking system usually records the date each candidate moved from one stage to the next, so the counts come from records rather than memory.
If most of the days sat in the search, an agency may fill the role faster. If they sat in the process, an agency’s candidates go through the same interviews and wait for the same feedback, so speed up the process first.
Use an agency where finding candidates is the delay.
An agency adds reach. A specialist agency may already know people in that field who aren’t looking for a job, and your team would take weeks to find them. An agency can also search without naming your company, or start a role your recruiters have no time for. Each of these helps on some kinds of role and not on others. Use this table as a starting point and change it for your team:
| Situation | Faster route | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A senior or specialist role your team rarely hires for | Agency | A specialist agency may already know the few people who fit and can approach them now |
| A first hire in a new city or country | Agency | Your team has no network there, and candidates there may not know your company |
| A confidential search, such as replacing someone still in the role | Agency | The agency can approach candidates without naming your company at first |
| A role your recruiters are too stretched to start this month | Agency, for now | The agency can start this week; if your team stays stretched, plan for more recruiting capacity |
| A role you hire for several times a year | In-house | Each hire leaves your team candidates and a brief the next search can use |
| A role whose last hire stalled on feedback and decisions | In-house, after fixing the process | An agency adds candidates to a queue that’s already slow |
For each role you hand to an agency, write one line on what it can do that your team can’t do now: reach, discretion, or capacity. If you can’t write that line, keep the role in-house.
Keep repeat roles with your in-house recruitment team.
A role you fill several times a year is where your own recruiters should beat any agency, because each hire leaves something the next hire can use:
- Candidates who reached the final rounds and weren’t hired, who may fit the next opening.
- A brief the hiring manager has already approved, so the search can start the day the role opens.
- Interviewers who know what a strong answer sounds like for this role.
- Job posts and outreach messages that already drew good candidates.
Compare your team’s first and second hire for the same role. If the second took just as long, split it into the search and the process, as you did above. If the days sat in the search, start the next one from the final-round candidates and the approved brief the last hire left. If they sat after the first interview, the process is the delay, and an agency won’t remove it.
Set the terms before an agency starts.
An agency speeds up a role only if your team moves its candidates through interviews as quickly as the agency sends them. Agree on these terms with the agency before it sends anyone:
- Share the written criteria the hiring manager approved, so the agency screens against the same list your team uses.
- Set a deadline for feedback on every candidate the agency sends, and name the person on your team who owns it.
- Agree who owns a candidate who’s already in your applicant tracking system, and how long the agency owns a candidate it sends you, so your team and the agency never approach the same person.
- Ask the agency to send its screening notes with each candidate, and decide what feedback you’ll send back.
- Agree on the fee, when it’s paid, and what happens to it if the hire doesn’t work out. The agency recommends candidates, and the hiring team makes every decision.
A separate guide covers what to send an agency after interviews and what to keep inside your team.
Agreeing on the role before anyone is approached is also where a good search firm starts. In the episode below, host Nolan Church talks with Annie Wenzel, a senior partner at Swing Search who places go-to-market executives in tech companies, about why a great search starts with alignment with the client rather than with speed.
Where Metaview fits.
Metaview is the Agentic Recruiting Platform. Whichever route you choose for a role, Metaview helps in two places: the interviews, where candidates from both routes meet the same hiring team, and the search on the roles your own recruiters keep.
Where consent has been given, the Metaview Notetaker records each interview and turns the conversation into structured notes. The recording captures every spoken word, so the debrief works from what each candidate said. A candidate an agency found gets the same record as one your own team found.
The Notetaker also drafts the scorecard from the interview, and the interviewer reviews and rates it before submitting. The interviewer starts from a draft instead of a blank form when the feedback deadline you set with the agency comes around.
When a role drags, a team can be tempted to decide with less information, such as a short agency note and the hiring manager’s memory of the interview. Siadhal Magos, Metaview’s co-founder and chief executive officer, has argued against exactly that:
I don’t think the answer to an information problem is making decisions with even less information.”
The second place is the search. That’s where artificial intelligence (AI) can help your own recruiters on the roles they keep. From one prompt, Metaview’s AI Sourcing agent searches the web, your connected applicant tracking system, and your team’s past conversations recorded in Metaview. It returns candidates with the reasoning for each. It doesn’t contact or assess anyone, so your recruiters decide who to approach.
How to tell whether your agency and in-house recruitment choices are working.
After a quarter, run these five checks on the roles you gave an agency and the roles you kept. Each check ends with what to change if it fails:
- Did the agency reach a first hiring manager interview with a candidate who met the brief sooner than your team did on its last search for that kind of role? If not, take the next role of that kind back in-house.
- Did agency candidates wait longer for feedback than your own candidates? If so, the delay is on your side, so hold the hiring team to the deadline you set.
- How many agency candidates met the written criteria at their first interview? If few did, go through the criteria again with the agency before it sends anyone else.
- Is your team’s second hire for each repeat role faster than its first? If not, find where its days went, as in the first section, before you add an agency.
- Did any candidate come to you from both your team and an agency? If so, tighten the ownership rule and share it with every agency you use.
Choose the route that removes the delay each role has. Give an agency the roles where your team can’t reach candidates quickly, keep the roles your recruiters fill again and again, and whichever route found the candidate, hold your hiring team to the same feedback deadline.
Keep every role moving after the first interview.
See how Metaview drafts each scorecard from the interview for the interviewer to review, and searches for candidates for your own recruiters.
Frequently asked.
Can you use an agency and in-house recruiters on the same role?
You can, if both sides work from the same written criteria and agree who owns each candidate before anyone reaches out. Give the agency a defined part of the search, such as target companies your own team isn’t covering, so the two searches don’t overlap.
Is a recruitment agency cheaper than an in-house recruiter?
An agency usually charges a fee for each hire, while a recruiter is paid a fixed salary. For a role you fill once or twice a year, the agency often costs less. For roles you fill many times a year, the recruiter usually works out cheaper for each hire, so count the hires you expect in the next year before you decide.
What should you ask a recruitment agency before it starts on a role?
Ask how it will find candidates for this role, and which companies it won’t approach because they’re its own clients. Then agree how it’ll screen against your criteria, and what happens to the fee if the hire doesn’t work out.
When should you build an in-house recruitment team instead of using agencies?
Build one once you hire the same kinds of role several times a year and the agency fees for them add up to more than a recruiter would cost. An in-house recruiter also keeps what each search turns up, such as candidates who came close, for the next opening.
Should an agency recruiter screen candidates before your team interviews them?
An agency recruiter should screen every candidate against your written criteria before sending them, and send the notes from that screen. The interviews that decide the hire stay with your team. At most, the agency’s screen can replace your own first call.