The recruiter runs the hiring process for a role, and the hiring manager, the person the new hire will work for, makes the hiring decision. Problems in the recruiter versus hiring manager relationship start at the handoffs between the two roles, where each side assumes the other owns the next move.
You can see these problems in an ordinary search. A candidate waits a week for feedback, because the recruiter is waiting on the hiring manager and the hiring manager expects the recruiter to follow up. The hiring manager repeats the screen the recruiter already ran. Then an offer goes out at a number the two never agreed on.
I recommend writing down who owns each step and how fast each handoff happens. Agree on both at the intake meeting, before the first candidate arrives, so neither side has to guess what the other will do next.
This guide is for recruiters and hiring managers working on the same search, and for the talent leaders who set how their teams work together. It sets out who owns each step of a hire and the response times to agree on. Then it covers how to write both down at intake as one agreement, how to keep that agreement on track during the search, and how to tell it’s working.
Recruiter versus hiring manager: who owns each step.
Break a hire into seven steps, and at each one the recruiter and the hiring manager own different parts of the work. Here’s a default split to start from, with what tends to happen when a step has no owner:
| Step | The recruiter owns | The hiring manager owns | When no one owns it |
|---|---|---|---|
| The brief | Running the intake meeting, testing the requirements against the market, and writing up what was agreed on | Setting the requirements, saying what would rule a candidate out, and signing off on the write-up | The requirements change halfway through the search |
| Sourcing | Finding candidates, choosing where to look, and reporting what the market looks like | Reviewing profiles on time, and naming people from their own network | The shortlist waits in an inbox |
| The first screen | Screening against the agreed requirements, and writing up what the candidate said | Reading the write-up before their own interview | The hiring manager repeats the screen |
| Turning candidates down | Telling each candidate, and recording the reason | Giving the reason for each no, on time | Candidates hear nothing |
| The interview loop | Scheduling the interviews and briefing each interviewer | Choosing the interviewers and what each one covers | Two interviewers ask the same questions |
| The decision | Running the debrief and recording the decision with its reasons | Making the hiring decision and explaining it | The decision stalls while the candidate waits |
| The offer | Learning the candidate’s pay expectations early, making the offer, and negotiating inside the range | Agreeing on the pay range at intake, before the job is posted, and approving anything outside it | The offer goes out at a number the two never agreed on |
Each row splits one step between two people, and the right-hand column shows what the split prevents. Those failures are what the two end up arguing about, and the cause is an unowned step rather than a clash of personalities.
The table covers the work on a single search. A separate guide to what a hiring manager does covers the role itself.
Agree on a response time for each handoff.
An owner tells each side what to do, and a response time tells them by when. The owners and the response times together make up a recruiting service level agreement (SLA). Start from these times, then change them to fit your team’s week:
- Shortlist feedback: the hiring manager answers on each profile within two business days.
- Screen write-up: the recruiter sends it within one business day of the screen.
- Interview feedback: each interviewer submits their scorecard within one business day of the interview, and before the debrief.
- Decision: the hiring manager decides within one business day of the debrief.
- Offer approval: anyone who signs off on an offer answers within one business day.
- Candidate updates: the recruiter tells every active candidate where they stand at least once a week.
Pick times both sides can keep in a busy week. A response time the hiring manager can’t keep teaches both sides to ignore the agreement, and the candidates waiting on it are the first to notice.
To hear how one talent team sets these times in practice, listen to Lucy Lynn, head of talent at Cleo, on the 10x Recruiting podcast. Lynn explains how the Cleo talent team sets service levels and scorecard requirements with hiring managers, and why the team won’t start a search until the role is documented.
Write the agreement down at the intake meeting.
The intake meeting is where the two of you agree on the brief, so it’s the natural place to agree on how you’ll work together too. Work through these steps before the role opens:
- Book the intake meeting before the job is posted, with both of you in the room.
- Agree on the requirements and what would rule a candidate out, and write them down in the hiring manager’s words.
- Go through the ownership table row by row, and change any row that doesn’t fit this search.
- Set the response time for each handoff, and agree on what happens when one is missed, such as the recruiter raising it at a short weekly check between the two of you.
- Agree on the pay range, and who can approve an offer outside it.
- Send both sides a written copy the same day. Keep it where both of you already look, such as the job’s record in your applicant tracking system (ATS).
Agreeing on the split and times adds one agenda item to intake.
A separate template of recruiter intake meeting questions covers what to ask about the role itself.
Keep the agreement working during the search.
An agreement written at intake starts to slip once candidates arrive and both calendars fill up. A fifteen-minute weekly check between the two of you catches the slip early. Run it on the same day each week:
- Go through every open candidate, and name who owes the next move and by when.
- Look at the past week’s handoffs, and name each response time that was missed.
- Look at the candidates turned down that week, and check that each one was told and a reason was recorded.
- When the same step keeps slipping, change its owner or its response time.
- Send the changed agreement to both sides the same day.
Keep the check short and about where each candidate stands. A disagreement about a candidate belongs in the debrief, where every interviewer’s feedback is in front of you.
Where Metaview fits.
Three handoffs in the agreement depend on what a candidate said in an interview: the screen write-up, each interviewer’s feedback, and the decision after the debrief. Each of those handoffs is only as good as the record of the interview behind it, and that record is where Metaview comes in.
Metaview is the Agentic Recruiting Platform. Where consent has been given, the Metaview Notetaker records and transcribes an interview, then turns the conversation into structured notes. The recording captures every spoken word, so a hiring manager who wasn’t in the screen reads what the candidate said instead of asking the recruiter for it.
The Notetaker also drafts the scorecard from the conversation. The interviewer reviews the draft, rates the candidate, and submits it, so the rating stays with the person who ran the interview.
The hiring manager can make the next write-ups better by telling interviewers which of their notes and scorecards helped with the decision. Shahriar Tajbakhsh, Metaview’s co-founder and chief technology officer, has described the debrief as the place to say so:
The debrief is a great opportunity for hiring managers to give feedback on the quality of the scorecards and note what was helpful or not in informing the ultimate decision.”
The notes and scorecards help only once they reach the place your hiring managers already read. Metaview sits alongside your ATS rather than inside it, and how scorecards reach the ATS depends on which ATS you use, so check where they land before you rely on them.
How to tell your recruiter and hiring manager agreement is working.
The weekly check catches a slipping handoff. A month into the search, step back and use these five checks to see whether the agreement as a whole is working:
- Can both of you name who owes the next move on every open candidate without looking it up? If not, go through the ownership table again at the next weekly check.
- Did each handoff land within its response time? If one keeps missing, change its owner or its time.
- Did the hiring manager interview candidates without repeating the screen? If they repeated it, look at what the screen write-up gave them.
- Was every candidate turned down told, with a reason recorded? If not, name who records the reason and by when.
- Did every offer go out inside the range agreed on at intake? If one didn’t, check that the approver named at intake signed off, and tighten that step before the next search.
When both of you can say who owns the next step and by when, the agreement is doing its job. Agree on the owners and the times before the next search starts, and the relationship stops depending on who follows up harder.
Give the hiring manager the whole screening call.
See how the Metaview Notetaker records and transcribes interviews where consent has been given, and drafts the scorecard for the interviewer to review.
Frequently asked.
What is the difference between a recruiter and a hiring manager?
A recruiter runs the hiring process for a role, from the search through to the offer. A hiring manager is the person the new hire will report to, who sets the requirements and decides who gets the job.
Who has the final say on a hire, the recruiter or the hiring manager?
The hiring manager has the final say, sometimes with a more senior approver for senior roles. The recruiter makes sure the decision rests on what the interviews found, and says so when a call departs from the requirements agreed on at intake.
What is a recruiting service level agreement?
A recruiting SLA is a written agreement between recruiting and the hiring manager on who owns each step of a search and how fast each side responds. A useful one covers the handoffs where candidates wait, such as feedback on candidates and offer approvals.
What should a recruiter do when a hiring manager doesn’t respond?
Raise it at the weekly check, with the candidates who are waiting and how long each has waited. If the same handoff keeps slipping, change the agreement: give that step a new owner or a longer response time.
How often should recruiters and hiring managers meet during a search?
A short weekly check suits most searches, with enough time to go through every open candidate and any missed response time. Add a meeting when the requirements change, rather than waiting for the next check.